These Editor-Approved Dress Shoes Are as Sharp as They Are Comfortable (2024)

Table of Contents
Best Overall Comfortable Dress Shoe Most comfortable business casual dress shoes Most Affordable Comfortable Dress Shoe Most Comfortable Wingtip Dress Shoe Most Comfortable Slip On Dress Shoe Most Comfortable Cap Toe Dress Shoe Most Comfortable Plain Toe Dress Shoe Most Comfortable Loafers Most Comfortable Dress Boots Most Comfortable Casual Dress Shoe Ecco Citytray Cap Toe Ecco Citytray Cap Toe Amberjack The Original Amberjack The Original Rockport DresSports 2 Go Plain Toe Shoe Rockport DresSports 2 Go Plain Toe Shoe ØriginalGrand Wingtip Oxford ØriginalGrand Wingtip Oxford Florsheim Hamptons Moc Toe Venetian Loafer Florsheim Hamptons Moc Toe Venetian Loafer Nunn Bush Centro Flex Cap Toe Oxford Nunn Bush Centro Flex Cap Toe Oxford Johnston & Murphy Upton Plain Toe Dark Brown Nubuck Johnston & Murphy Upton Plain Toe Dark Brown Nubuck G.H. Bass Larson Suede EVA Weejuns Loafer G.H. Bass Larson Suede EVA Weejuns Loafer Astorflex Bitflex Chelsea Boot Astorflex Bitflex Chelsea Boot Florsheim Frenzi Perf Toe Oxford Florsheim Frenzi Perf Toe Oxford Crockett & Jones Hallam Cap-toe Shoe Crockett & Jones Hallam Cap-toe Shoe Four More of the Most Comfortable Dress Shoes Allen Edmonds William Wingtip Derby Allen Edmonds William Wingtip Derby Nisolo Everyday Oxford Nisolo Everyday Oxford Born Coquette Born Coquette Ecco ST1 Hybrid Plain Toe Tie Ecco ST1 Hybrid Plain Toe Tie What to Look For in Comfortable Dress Shoes What to Look For in Comfortable Dress Shoes How to Style Comfortable Dress Shoes How to Style Comfortable Dress Shoes Read More About the Most Comfortable Shoes to Buy Now Read More About the Most Comfortable Shoes to Buy Now Read More About the Best Dress Clothes to Buy Now Read More About the Best Dress Clothes to Buy Now FAQs
These Editor-Approved Dress Shoes Are as Sharp as They Are Comfortable (1)

Our product picks are editor-tested, expert-approved. We may earn a commission through links on our site. Why Trust Us?

Men's dress shoes have remained relatively unchanged for the past century. We’re still wearing oxfords and derby shoes with plain toes, cap toes, and wingtips. Loafers still come in the penny, tassel, and venetian varieties. The biggest change in dress shoes is how we wear them. Nowadays, guys want dress shoes that are as comfortable as they are handsome, and our favorite menswear brands have happily obliged, churning out top-notch tuxedo shoes, slip-on shoes, and even dress slippers with next-level cushioning found in some of our favorite walking shoes.

Today, the most comfortable dress shoes have soles that cushion and cradle our feet, absorb the pressure of our steps, and provide superior traction. Dress shoe uppers have also been upgraded with padding around the ankle, in the tongue, and interiors. Most importantly, all these changes have been made without changing the overall appearance of dress shoes that we know and love.

The most comfortable dress shoes we've tested have performance features like rubber, foam, and polymer soles. Their insoles contain memory foam and gel pads at key pressure points, especially the heel, which makes them look and function more like orthopedic inserts than old school leather and cork insoles. Many comfortable dress shoes even replaced heels with flat, sneaker-like soles. For long days at the office, long nights on your feet, or just striking that balance between looking classy and feeling comfy, these are the most comfortable dress shoes for men right now.

Ecco does an excellent job of concealing all the comfortable upgrades to keep the Citrytray Cap Toe looking like an old school dress shoe. The removable orthopedic insole, which is replaceable when it wears out, is even covered with a layer of leather to look like an old fashioned dress shoe on the inside. Ecco's Citrytray midsole and outsole system provides the kind of traction and stability you find in a walking shoe. A simple cap toe derby in brown or black is as useful and reliable a dress shoe as you can find. This will keep your feet happy at work, on wedding dance floors, and any time you're on the move.

Sizes6 -13
WidthsMedium
ColorsBrown and black
Upper MaterialLeather
Sole MaterialRubber

Most comfortable business casual dress shoes

Amberjack The Original

These Editor-Approved Dress Shoes Are as Sharp as They Are Comfortable (13)

Most comfortable business casual dress shoes

Amberjack The Original

Step into something comfortable first before you step into success, like in these business casual shoes that are nothing but supportive and stylish. Having owned and worn these for several months, I can say with confidence that these are perhaps the most comfortable dress shoes I’ve ever tested—all thanks to Amberjack’s athletic performance build. The memory foam arch support plus the flexible outsole with extra support in the heel are both designed to let your feet move in comfort, and the upper is made with flexible materials. The construction makes it a pair of dress shoes that won’t tire my feet out since it's soft and easy to break in yet very sturdy.

Sizes7 - 15
WidthsOne size/medium
Colors12 options to choose from
Upper materialLeather or suede
Sole materialThermoplastic polyurethane

Most Affordable Comfortable Dress Shoe

Rockport DresSports 2 Go Plain Toe Shoe

These Editor-Approved Dress Shoes Are as Sharp as They Are Comfortable (14)

These Editor-Approved Dress Shoes Are as Sharp as They Are Comfortable (15)

Most Affordable Comfortable Dress Shoe

Rockport DresSports 2 Go Plain Toe Shoe

Some comfortable dress shoes take clear inspiration from sneakers, the DresSports from Rockport is one of them. While this is essentially a plain toe leather derby, the rubber midsole and ankle padding come from more casual footwear. Those tweaks are made without disrupting the overall dress shoe look. The all white sole contrasts nicely with the brown or black upper to create a business causal look. These are great work shoes laidback office dress codes.

Read more: Best Men's Leather Sneakers

Sizes7 - 15
WidthsMedium and wide
ColorsCaramel and black
Upper materialLeather
Sole materialRubber

Advertisem*nt - Continue Reading Below

Most Comfortable Wingtip Dress Shoe

ØriginalGrand Wingtip Oxford

These Editor-Approved Dress Shoes Are as Sharp as They Are Comfortable (16)

These Editor-Approved Dress Shoes Are as Sharp as They Are Comfortable (17)

Most Comfortable Wingtip Dress Shoe

ØriginalGrand Wingtip Oxford

Now 24% Off

Wingtip dress shoes are one of those old-fashioned styles that have managed to stick around because they just always work. Whether you're rocking a t-shirt and jeans or a three-piece suit, wingtip oxfords place the perfect accent on your fit. Up top, Cole Haan nails the classic look with just enough brogue detail (those perforated holes in the leather) to show off the wing design without overdoing it. While several layers of cushion and support in the insole and midsole pamper your feet. You can go with black or white leather in either black or white soles, plus there is a gorgeous oxblood leather option with a black sole.

Sizes7 - 16
WidthsMedium and Wide
ColorsBlack/white, brown/white, brown/dark brown, black/black, gray/white, and oxblood/black
Upper materialLeather
Sole MaterialRubber

Most Comfortable Slip On Dress Shoe

Florsheim Hamptons Moc Toe Venetian Loafer

These Editor-Approved Dress Shoes Are as Sharp as They Are Comfortable (18)

Most Comfortable Slip On Dress Shoe

Florsheim Hamptons Moc Toe Venetian Loafer

Now 13% Off

Venetian loafers have a sleeker aesthetic than penny or tassel loafers because those extra details are removed. Florsheim makes an elevated slip on comfortable dress shoe with their venetian style Hamptons. The molded rubber sole has a slightly athletic look but the matte black color keeps it dressy. These are great for weddings, social events, and just dressing up for the fun of it on your time off.

Sizes7 - 14
WidthsMedium and wide
ColorsGray, black, cognac, brown, tan, navy, and blue
Upper materialLeather or suede
Sole materialRubber

Most Comfortable Cap Toe Dress Shoe

Nunn Bush Centro Flex Cap Toe Oxford

These Editor-Approved Dress Shoes Are as Sharp as They Are Comfortable (19)

Most Comfortable Cap Toe Dress Shoe

Nunn Bush Centro Flex Cap Toe Oxford

Now 20% Off

These may look like some standard issue cap toe oxford shoes, but Nunn Bush packed the insole and midsole with soothing little details. Gel and foam inserts support your weight and provide bounce in your step. Flexible midsoles and outsoles bend in a natural motion with your feet as you walk. The heel is low to prevent too much pressure on the balls of your feet. These are classic formalwear shoes to wear with suiting or office attire.

Sizes7 - 14
WidthsMedium and wide
ColorsBlack, brown, and cognac
Upper materialLeather
Sole materialSynthetic rubber

Advertisem*nt - Continue Reading Below

Most Comfortable Plain Toe Dress Shoe

Johnston & Murphy Upton Plain Toe Dark Brown Nubuck

These Editor-Approved Dress Shoes Are as Sharp as They Are Comfortable (20)

Most Comfortable Plain Toe Dress Shoe

Johnston & Murphy Upton Plain Toe Dark Brown Nubuck

Nubuck leather is buttery soft and much easier on your feet than a standard leather dress shoe. Johnston & Murphy added a mesh lining on the inside to help your feet breath and cut down on weight. The result in a chocolate brown upper that looks great and feels even better. On the inside, you've got a removable memory foam insole over a bouncy composite foam outsole. These beauties will keep the pep in your step during long days at the office. Plus, they look great with chinos and slacks.

Sizes8 - 13
WidthsMedium
ColorsBrown nubuck, gray nubuck, white nubuck, black leather, brown leather, and tan leather
Upper materialLeather
Sole materialTruFoam EVA Composite

Most Comfortable Loafers

G.H. Bass Larson Suede EVA Weejuns Loafer

These Editor-Approved Dress Shoes Are as Sharp as They Are Comfortable (21)

Most Comfortable Loafers

G.H. Bass Larson Suede EVA Weejuns Loafer

G.H. Bass makes some of the worlds finest loafers at very friendly prices. The signature Weejuns penny loafers typically come in all leather but a far more comfortable alternative is the suede upper with EVA sole. Suede and softer and more flexible so there is little-to-no breaking in required. You also get that fuzzy matte texture which looks great with jeans and chinos. Most of the comfort, however, comes from the EVA sole which is lighter, more flexible, and provides a bouncy step, compared to leather soles. It is also much cheaper to resole.

Sizes7 - 13
WidthsMedium
ColorsDenim, sage, and desert sand
Upper materialSuede
Sole materialEVA

Most Comfortable Dress Boots

Astorflex Bitflex Chelsea Boot

These Editor-Approved Dress Shoes Are as Sharp as They Are Comfortable (22)

Most Comfortable Dress Boots

Astorflex Bitflex Chelsea Boot

Chelsea boots are not only the dressiest of all boot varieties, they are also one of the most popular footwear options for men this fall. Astorflex makes one of the most comfortable Chelsea boots out there and they look fantastic, to boot. The leather is soft and flexible, requiring minimal breaking in. The gusset is extra wide providing ample flexibility in the ankle. Best of all is the cushioning and traction provided by the crepe rubber sole. It acts like a natural spring, expanding and contracting with every step, while gripping to the ground as you walk. Dress them up with slacks or chinos, or go rugged with jeans.

Sizes7 - 14
WidthsMedium
ColorsBlack, tobacco suede, stone suede, chestnut nubuck, and tan leather
Upper materialLeather or suede
Sole materialCrepe rubber

Advertisem*nt - Continue Reading Below

Most Comfortable Casual Dress Shoe

Florsheim Frenzi Perf Toe Oxford

These Editor-Approved Dress Shoes Are as Sharp as They Are Comfortable (23)

Most Comfortable Casual Dress Shoe

Florsheim Frenzi Perf Toe Oxford

Now 14% Off

The Conquette from Florsheim may be bordering on sneaker territory. Though the welt stitch and derby style leather upper are enough to pass for dress shoes under the right circ*mstances. If you have a relaxed work dress code or are looking to elevate above sneakers without losing the comfort, these are the shoes for you. The perforated upper, padded ankle and tongue, and pretty much the entire sole provide the feel of a top-end running sneaker.

Sizes7 - 14
WidthsMedium and Wide
ColorsTan, navy, and gray
Upper materialNubuck leather
Sole materialLightweight composite

Most Comfortable Luxury Dress Shoe

Crockett & Jones Hallam Cap-toe Shoe

These Editor-Approved Dress Shoes Are as Sharp as They Are Comfortable (24)

Most Comfortable Luxury Dress Shoe

Crockett & Jones Hallam Cap-toe Shoe

Crockett & Jones is one of the most well respected shoe makers in the world. The brand shows that using the absolute best materials and craftsmanship can provide as much comfort as the best performance sneakers out there. Every piece of this shoe is hand crafted to provide your feet with maximum comfort. If your budget allows for there, there is no better experience for your feet.

Sizes6 - 14
WidthsMedium
ColorsBlack
Upper materialLeather
Sole materialLeather with rubber outsole

Four More of the Most Comfortable Dress Shoes

These Editor-Approved Dress Shoes Are as Sharp as They Are Comfortable (25)

Advertisem*nt - Continue Reading Below

Allen Edmonds William Wingtip Derby

These Editor-Approved Dress Shoes Are as Sharp as They Are Comfortable (26)

Allen Edmonds William Wingtip Derby

Now 47% Off

A sandy suede wingtip derby is the perfect fall dress shoe. It works well with slacks and chinos at the office and plays well with jeans on the weekends. Allen Edmonds built the Williams Wingtip Derby with signature XL Extralight injection molded outsoles to cut down on weight and provide cushioning in your step.

Sizes7 - 14
WidthsMedium
ColorsWalnut leather, dark brown leather, bone suede, and denim suede
Upper materialLeather or suede
Sole materialXL Extralight®

Nisolo Everyday Oxford

These Editor-Approved Dress Shoes Are as Sharp as They Are Comfortable (27)

Nisolo Everyday Oxford

Black oxford shoes look good with just about everything. Nisolo set the Eevryday Oxford apart with a custom designed five layer memory foam insole that keeps your feet happy all day. The wider, boot style toe box also provides ample room for your toes to spread naturally as you walk.

Read more: Best Black Sneakers

Sizes8 - 13
WidthsMedium
ColorsBlack, brandy, brown, and tobacco
Upper materialLeather
Sole materialLeather with rubber outsole

Born Coquette

These Editor-Approved Dress Shoes Are as Sharp as They Are Comfortable (28)

Born built an archetypical leather wingtip upper on a flat soled sneaker-style rubber sole. A padded insole provides an additional layer of comfort. The Croquette is truly the best of both worlds, making it an ideal office shoe.

Sizes 8 -13
WidthsMedium
ColorsBlue, brown, and taupe
Upper materialLeather
Sole matterialRubber

Advertisem*nt - Continue Reading Below

Ecco ST1 Hybrid Plain Toe Tie

These Editor-Approved Dress Shoes Are as Sharp as They Are Comfortable (29)

Ecco put a genuine athletic shoe sole on a luxuriously supple pebble grain leather. You could probably go for a long walk in the ST1 Hybrid if you needed to, although we don't recommend it. However, kicking around in them for long days on the job or traveling is highly recommended.

Sizes6 - 13
WidthsMedium
ColorsBrown, cognac, and black
Upper materialLeather
Sole materialEcco Shock Thru composite sole

What to Look For in Comfortable Dress Shoes

These Editor-Approved Dress Shoes Are as Sharp as They Are Comfortable (30)

Fit: Just as with any other shoe, finding the right fit is nailing that middle ground between cramped and loose. If your feet are compressed for long periods of time it can not only cause foot pain but negatively affect the rest of your body by throwing off how you naturally carry your weight. Too much room, on the other hand, and you will cause friction that results in blisters. When you try on a pair of shoes, make sure you can wiggle your toes and spread them out. Comfortable dress shoes avoid the pointed toes that looked nice on some traditional dress shoes, but are not friendly to toes. You also want to make sure your heel sits firmly against the back of the shoe as you take a few steps.

Color: To maintain a proper dress shoe look, you want to stick with the usual colors like black, brown, gray, blue, and cognac for the upper. If you’re going with suede, a lighter sandy tan color is a good choice. Soles may contain composites of various materials but they should be a uniform color, or close to. A solid black, brown, or white sole is preferable. Contrasting between the sole and upper is a good look, like a brown upper and white sole for instance. Avoid bright colors or sporty patterns that you might find on a sneaker.

Sole Material: All three layers of the sole have seen significant upgrades in comfortable dress shoes. Insoles are more comforting with modern materials like memory foam and gel pads. Midsoles are ergonomically shaped to provide arch support, heel cradling, and absorb toe pressure. Whole slippery leather outsoles have been replaced with firm gripping rubber. Whether you go for a classic heel or an athletic style flat sole, your feet are getting pampered.

Upper Material: There are plenty of comfortable dress shoes out there that have strayed too far into athletic shoe territory by ditching the leather, or at least leather-looking uppers. It is important not to lose the “dress” part of dress shoes by wearing something that looks like a fancy trainer. The best shoe makers are using softer, more accommodating leather to retain that familiar dress shoe look while enhancing comfort. The rule of thumb is: As long as the upper looks dressy, the sole can be more athletic.

How to Style Comfortable Dress Shoes

These Editor-Approved Dress Shoes Are as Sharp as They Are Comfortable (31)

Comfortable dress shoes are an excellent suiting hack, as long as you stick to a pair that looks more traditional. For professional use, every workplace has different wardrobe guidelines, but wool, cotton, or blended slacks work pretty much universally. Chinos are a comfortable business-casual favorite that always look good with comfortable dress shoes, as long as your workplace allows them. As for above the waist, a collared dress shirt is never the wrong answer. Oxford shirts are pretty much the shirting equivalent of comfortable dress shoes: classic look with a cozy feel. Investing in some solid, dark colored crew neck sweaters in either wool or cashmere is a great office wear alternative for the colder months.

Advertisem*nt - Continue Reading Below

Read More About the Most Comfortable Shoes to Buy Now

These Editor-Approved Dress Shoes Are as Sharp as They Are Comfortable (32)

Best Shoes for Standing All Day in | Most Breathable Sneakers | Best Arch Support Shoes | Best Dad Shoes | Best Shoes for Bunions | Best Dress Sneakers | Best Canvas Sneakers

Read More About the Best Dress Clothes to Buy Now

These Editor-Approved Dress Shoes Are as Sharp as They Are Comfortable (33)

Best Dress Shirts for Men | Best White Dress Shirts | Best Suits for Men | Best Blazers for Men | co*cktail Attire for Men

These Editor-Approved Dress Shoes Are as Sharp as They Are Comfortable (34)

Brad Lanphear

Contributing Commerce Style Writer

Brad is a contributing style commerce editor. After a decade working for menswear brands including J.Crew and Ralph Lauren, Brad switched from selling fashion to writing about it. His words have appeared in Huckberry, Heddels, and The Manual.

These Editor-Approved Dress Shoes Are as Sharp as They Are Comfortable (35)

Reviewed byChristian Gollayan

Deputy Editor, Commerce

Christian Gollayan oversees e-commerce content for Men's Health and Women's Health. Previously, he was the Associate Managing Editor at TheManual.com. Christian's work has also been featured in Food & Wine, InStyle, the New York Post, and Tatler Asia.

These Editor-Approved Dress Shoes Are as Sharp as They Are Comfortable (2024)

FAQs

Are dress shoes supposed to be comfortable? ›

The shoes should feel comfortable without feeling tight. If they feel tight, loosen the laces and try again. If the laces are as loose as they can be, and the shoes are still too tight, try a wide width.

How can I make my dress shoes more comfortable? ›

You can try to increase the comfort of your dress shoes by stretching or resoling them, conditioning them, changing the type of socks you wear with them, and supportive insoles. Some men's dress shoe brands focus on making a more comfortable shoe. Consider brands like Allen Edmonds, Neil M, Ecco, and Cole Haan.

How can you tell if dress shoes are high quality? ›

High quality shoes will be made from leather, including the sole. There are different types of leather available but the best leather you want for your dress shoes should be full grain leather. The second part to look out for is whether the shoes have been machine or hand cut.

What are conservative dress shoes? ›

Business formal is the dressiest option and typically refers to full suiting in conservative cuts and colors. Your footwear should be equally dressy (think oxfords or loafers for men, and a dressy shoe with a heel for women). Shoes should always be closed-toe and should coordinate with your business formal attire.

Why do my feet hurt in dress shoes? ›

Women's dress shoes, particularly high heels, often feature a narrow forefoot, which increases the pressure on the balls of your feet. You can never truly take a balanced step in this footwear. Bunions, hammertoes, ingrown toenails and other recurring blisters are often the result.

How do I stop my dress shoes from hurting? ›

How to Stop Shoes From Rubbing the Back of Your Heel?
  1. Change the socks you wear. ...
  2. Use adhesive tape or pads. ...
  3. Apply powder to fight moisture. ...
  4. Use orthotics. ...
  5. Make sure your shoes are the right size. ...
  6. Make sure you know your shoe size. ...
  7. Keep your feet (and shoes) dry. ...
  8. Protect injured parts of your foot.
May 25, 2023

How do you break in uncomfortable dress shoes? ›

Day One: Wear your new shoes for 30 minutes inside, walking around in the afternoon or evening when your feet are the most swollen. Day Two: Wear your shoes for 60 minutes inside and outside. If your shoes are particularly tight—especially dress shoes—you can wear thick hiking socks to stretch them out further.

How do you soften dress shoes? ›

HOW TO STRETCH AND SOFTEN LEATHER BOOTS AND SHOES
  1. It can take a while for new footwear to feel like it's been in your wardrobe forever. ...
  2. 1) Wear them little and often. ...
  3. 2) Wear them indoors. ...
  4. 3) Use a spoon. ...
  5. 4) Use the hairdryer. ...
  6. 5) Use screwed up newspaper. ...
  7. 6) Buy shoe stretchers. ...
  8. 7) Use a stretching spray.

Do shoes get more comfortable the more you wear them? ›

It's best practice to never assume shoes will “break in.” Some will get a little more comfortable over time, but most will retain their original fit. Don't shove your feet into a pair of shoes assuming they'll stretch out or adjust to the shape of your feet later on.

Which sole is best for dress shoes? ›

Leather soles

Another advantage is that they are breathable. Therefore, your feet don't sweat when you are wearing leather shoes. Leather soles can also take up the foot shape of the wearer. These soles are ideal for formal shoes.

What is high end grade shoes? ›

A grade shoes:

Shoes without any functional defects or cosmetic defects that will impair the marketability of the shoe are A grade. These are high-quality shoes, they look good and fit correctly. An A grade must follow the production specifications and match the approved confirmation sample.

Should dress shoes be pointy? ›

A longer and more pointed last (sometimes referred to as aggressive) will feel more formal. It will elongate the foot. It lends itself better to the sharp and crisp lines of dress pants. A more rounded shaped last is the opposite.

What is the difference between dress shoes and formal shoes? ›

Formal shoes also are called dress shoes as they can be worn when ' dressing up ' – suits, blazers, shirts, trousers, etc. thanks to their elegant aesthetics, they are the stylish fit for a business/ formal setting where conventions and conformity matter, just like the office, and marriages.

What are the most formal dress shoes? ›

Oxfords are the most formal type of dress shoe. They have a closed lacing system and a vamp that is attached to the quarters of the shoe. Derbys are less formal than Oxfords. They have an open lacing system and a vamp that is not attached to the quarters of the shoe.

Should your toes touch the end of dress shoes? ›

If you feel the toes touching the tip of the shoes while stepping forward or on tip-toe, you'll need a larger size.

Do dress shoes fit differently than regular shoes? ›

Unlike sneakers, where there is some give and take, leather dress shoes are designed to fit close to your foot and eventually mold to its shape, feeling essentially like an extension of your appendage. If a shoe doesn't fit correctly, that can't happen.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Kelle Weber

Last Updated:

Views: 6248

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (53 voted)

Reviews: 84% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Kelle Weber

Birthday: 2000-08-05

Address: 6796 Juan Square, Markfort, MN 58988

Phone: +8215934114615

Job: Hospitality Director

Hobby: tabletop games, Foreign language learning, Leather crafting, Horseback riding, Swimming, Knapping, Handball

Introduction: My name is Kelle Weber, I am a magnificent, enchanting, fair, joyous, light, determined, joyous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.